|
How LUCKY We ARE to have THESE recordings!
Well, I guess it's time I added my comments on these recordings.
First, however, I'd like to say that I do not understand "bashing". This has been going on, in my remembrance at least, since Callas/Tebaldi in the 50's. How stupid is this! Does one REALLY think that two different singers, with two different voices and/or approaches to a role can be, truthfully, compared to one another? I have never understood this kind of thinking. I LOVE Callas (in nearly everything she sang), but she had an ugly voice....do I let this bother me or lead me to compare her to others??? NO! She was, unquestionably, the greatest singing actress of our time, period! Tebaldi...was there EVER a voice as beautiful as hers?? Sills...Was there ever a voice as light and as fresh as hers??? Sutherland?? She wasn't called La Stupenda for nothing, folks. I could go on, but I think the point is made. Every one of these singers (and others) are themselves, with their own interpretations of roles. Some sing some roles better than others, but bashing??? I don't think so!!! This shows one's uncomfortable shallowness quite clearly, I believe.
The review:
Sills had a wonderously light and silvery voice, that I find quite her own. I simply love her Baby Doe, and her Traviata, as her voice is simply made for the parts. Her Lucia is, also, really good. Casting her as the three Tudor Queens was a wonderful thing, it made her a real solid star at the New York City Opera. She was the only one singing these roles at the time, and it was good for her career, and, also, good for the music world to become familiar with these three great tragic, long neglected, works of Donizetti.
But, as they were really beyond the capability of her instrument, she, eventually, damaged her voice with the parts, especially Elizabeth in Roberto Deveraux. This is, I guess, inevitable, as most singers do at some point in their careers, delve deeply into waters beyond their capability, and the downward progression begins. Repeatedly, singer after singer has done this.
That aside, let me say that we are so very fortunate to have these three recordings, even with their flaws (and there certainly are flaws), both as a remembrance of Beverly Sills, and her colleagues, but also documentation of her performances and the presentation of Donizetti's works. All three of these works are so rarely performed, much less recorded, that they are a treasure for sure.
Personally, Roberto Deveraux, I feel, hangs together the strongest in Mackerras' leadership. Sills is, admittedly, pushing the limits of her capabilities...but, by doing the role in sessions, she is really very good on the recording. Admittedly, in a live performance, straight through, there is the electricity of interaction with other characters on stage, taking the heights up a notch, and this is where she really did the damage to her voice. Her compatriots here are all really serviceable...we are so lucky to have this recording, why be objectionally picky? DG has done a remarkable job remastering this particular recording. I remember the ABC pressing on LP years ago, and am pleased with the care attended here to the remastering.
Maria Stuarda, is, again, another special recording....Eileen Farrell came out of retirement to do this recording as a favor to Beverly, and we are very lucky to have them paired together. I must admit that I wish Mackerras was again at the helm here, however. There is no doubt in my mind that the whole would have been greater with his control and "color" on the orchestra. But, with the only other exceptions the old Callas with great cuts, and the Sutherland, we have few choices, and we take this recording most gladly. It is commendable.
I feel that Anna Bolena is the weakest of the three works, but it has some extrodinary things in it, particularly the confrontation in the garden! Man, the first time I heard this, I stood right up out of my chair! Paul Plishka was a wonderful Henry, and Shirley Verrett certainly made her mark with Jane Seymour. Again, most commendable.
I, as stated above, remember the old ABC LP pressings....they were terrible, as we all know! It is so wonderful to have these recordings, again, this time in pristine, lovingly remastered editions. Thank You, DG/Universal for lavishing the care on these lovely old recordings that you have for our enjoyment.
A tremendous, and fitting, tribute to Beverly Sills.
I might add that I feel you might wish to pick up this set very soon, as lately things have been getting re-issued in budget sets without libretti and informational booklets, and this is a shame, especially with a great set like this one. Also, noting the complaints about them being so "expensive"....come on, folks, wise up!!! You're getting three operas here for $80 or less, through secondary dealers, just how expensive does one really think this is? OK, enough preaching! Enjoy this set, and be thankful that we have it! ~operabruin
[Saturday, July 07, 2007]
|
